Hill Top Inn Information

Nestled on the scenic hills of Elmira, New York, Hill Top Inn offers a delightful retreat with a warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. Situated at 171 Jerusalem Hill Rd, this beloved local gem has been serving the community and visitors for years, providing both hearty meals and a relaxed dining experience. As soon as you step inside, the cozy charm of this restaurant is evident, with its rustic decor and attentive service making it an inviting place for friends, families, or even a quiet solo meal.

The menu at Hill Top Inn boasts a great variety of options, catering to diverse tastes and preferences. From classic American comfort food to more contemporary dishes, there’s something for everyone. A favorite among regulars is the tender prime rib, which is cooked to perfection and served alongside fluffy mashed potatoes and fresh seasonal vegetables. For those in the mood for lighter fare, the house salad with a tangy vinaigrette offers a refreshing start to any meal. The seafood options are also a standout, with the shrimp scampi being a particularly popular choice, praised for its flavorful, garlicky sauce and perfectly cooked shrimp.

What sets Hill Top Inn apart is not just its food but the warm and friendly service. The staff are attentive without being intrusive, always ready to offer recommendations or make sure your glass is never empty. It’s easy to see why locals return time and again; the genuine care and pride in service create a sense of belonging and comfort. The relaxed vibe is perfect for casual dining, but it also works well for special occasions, thanks to the inviting ambiance and great menu.

While the food is consistently satisfying, the real draw of Hill Top Inn might just be its location. The restaurant’s hilltop setting offers scenic views of the surrounding area, making it a peaceful spot for a meal. Whether you're enjoying a sunny afternoon or a cozy evening, the view from the windows adds a special touch to your dining experience. There’s nothing quite like savoring a delicious meal while taking in the beauty of the countryside.

In addition to its regular menu, Hill Top Inn offers seasonal specials, which allow guests to explore new flavors throughout the year. The winter months bring heartier dishes, such as slow-cooked stews and soups, while summer offers fresh salads and lighter options perfect for the warmer weather. It’s clear that the restaurant takes pride in using quality ingredients that are both locally sourced and fresh.

Whether you’re in the mood for a casual meal with friends, a romantic dinner, or a special family gathering, Hill Top Inn checks all the boxes. The combination of tasty food, great service, and a charming atmosphere makes it a standout choice in the Elmira area.

Most Popular Dishes

  • Grilled Buffalo Wings $
  • Tuna Appetizer $
  • Calamari $
  • Blue Point Oysters $
  • Eggs Benedict $
  • Smoked Wings $

Open Times

Monday Closed

Tuesday 05:00 PM - 08:00 PM

Wednesday 05:00 PM - 08:30 PM

Thursday 05:00 PM - 08:30 PM

Friday 05:00 PM - 09:00 PM

Saturday 05:00 PM - 09:00 PM

Sunday Closed

Icon

Location & Contact

Contact Details

  • 171 Jerusalem Hill Rd, Elmira, NY 14901, United States
  • Right Now :

What People's Say About Place

Beautiful restaurant and outdoors! Staff is knowledgeable and friendly. Except they didn’t know what the Irish/American flag on the wall was LOL. Owner is very hospitable. We were a party of 5 and all the food came out very fast.

Amazing! I reserved a table for 2 for my wife's birthday! The food was the best ive had in a long time for the style and price range. The server, Nick, was awesome and made sure our needs were well attended to. Food was prompt, hot, and delicious. 10/10

We made an unplanned stop at this restaurant on our way back to NYC from Niagara Falls and were lucky to find it. The views were stunning, and the staff was prompt and helpful. There was plenty of parking and seating, and we chose a table with a scenic view. They served complimentary fresh bread and butter, which was a nice touch. I loved the Grilled Buffalo Wings—smoky and flavorful. With the staff's recommendation, I also tried the Scallops, Flash-Baked Salmon, and Ratatouille with wild rice. While all the food was fresh, the wings were the standout for me. A perfect mix of good food and great views!

First, it has incredibly beautiful views and an outside eating area. The food was delicious with nice portion size. But, the best thing about this restaurant is the owner and the staff. They just made everything better!! Great attitudes and professionalism, and they go out of their way to make sure you have a great time!

A couple months ago, I attended a local community event hosted here. I’ve lived in the area for several years and that was my first time there. Tonight, for our anniversary, I knew we had to go back. Mike and his team did an amazing job taking care of us. The outside view was beautiful and sunny, the music/entertainment was good, and the food & service was excellent! I highly recommend this restaurant - the grilled buffalo wings & bread pudding bites were my favorite!!!

Had my wedding here, came for Valentine’s Day and had an amazing time both times! These people know hospitality! And their food is amazing. It’s beautiful up on the hill top.

Table of six on a very busy Friday night. You wouldn’t have known it. The service was so superb from start to finish. It appears that the staff all work together to make the evening perfect. Our “main” server, Taryn, was so professional, fun and attentive. But the other staff who delivered and checked on us were also awesome. Mike Sullivan, you should be proud! All of our meals (mostly fish fry) were done perfectly.

The wait was a bit long for our reservation time slot. However, our waiter, Zach, was excellent .The food was fabulous. The atmosphere was beautiful. Desserts were delicious, and everyone enjoyed our 1st visit here for the annual Easter buffet. Even one of the meat slicers gave me a wonderful tip lesson or even reverse my Lyme disease so I might one day enjoy red meat on occassional special days, if I followed his advise! Ty, I will try his suggestion!

Places Nearby